Skip to content

How Fetal Monitoring Errors Can Lead to Preventable Harm

Fetal monitor screen showing an ultrasound during laborThere’s nothing more exciting—and nerve-wracking—than welcoming a new life into your family. The joy of a newborn mixes with the fear for their well-being. Unfortunately, birth complications happen all too often. Fetal monitoring is a tool used during labor to assess fetal well-being and identify signs that may require intervention.

Through fetal monitoring and timely interventions, medical professionals aim to reduce the risk of complications from intrapartum hypoxia, such as hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE).

Where a serious issue can arise is if fetal monitoring is misinterpreted, not monitored often enough, or responses are delayed. This can increase the risk of fetal injury and potentially cause lifelong disability or stillbirth.

How continuous fetal monitoring works

Fetal monitoring may also be referred to as fetal heart rate tracing. It refers to a medical device that tracks a baby’s heart rate during labor.

During healthy labor, a baby’s heart rate will be variable. It will respond to contractions and then recover between. If abnormalities appear, it can indicate a lack of oxygen to the baby. Changes in the baby’s heart rate can provide medical personnel with signs that warrant evaluation for possible fetal hypoxia or acidemia. Fetal distress might mean that the baby is experiencing a lack of oxygen to their brain. If this is the case, swift action must be taken to ensure their safety.

Fetal tracings are typically grouped into three categories:

  • Category I: normal
  • Category II: needs close supervision and further evaluation
  • Category III: abnormal, associated with abnormal fetal acid-base status, and requiring prompt evaluation and intervention

If a Category III fetal tracing does not improve with initial interventions, expedited delivery is recommended; depending on the circumstances, this may be operative vaginal or cesarean delivery.

Fetal monitoring happens in real time, but data is also recorded and saved through a monitoring strip. This strip can be reviewed during labor and later on. Parents have the right to request access to these and other medical records.

Monitoring of fetal heart tracings is not passive. It requires frequent, active assessment and interpretation. If abnormalities appear, they require evaluation and, when indicated, intervention. If a Category III tracing does not improve after initial intervention, expedited delivery is recommended. Simply recording data is not enough. The data must be interpreted and acted upon.

Common errors in monitoring or interpretation

While fetal monitoring is regularly taught and is well understood, injuries do still happen.

A 2025 study from Finland, published in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, found that 49.6% of term HIE cases with normal admission cardiotocography were potentially avoidable. Overall, 22.3% of all term HIE cases in the study could have benefited from preventive measures.

Most concerning in cases of fetal monitoring negligence is a disconnect between interpretation and action. Often, medical records show that fetal distress is present and noted, but no action is taken. Proper treatment of fetal distress requires medical intervention.

Medical interventions when fetal distress is noted might include:

  • Repositioning the mother
  • Providing supplemental oxygen if the mother is hypoxic
  • Giving the mother IV fluids to improve hydration
  • Performing an emergency C-section

Monitoring and interpretation errors may happen for many reasons, including:

  • Shift changes where staff volume is lower
  • Improper staffing due to funding cuts
  • Assuming other people are monitoring or handling the situation
  • High-risk pregnancies with known complications
  • Breakdowns in communication between nurses and physicians
  • Prioritizing vaginal delivery over fetal safety

Systemic failures or clinical decisions may be relevant to whether the applicable standard of care was met. Hospitals are required to provide care consistent with the applicable standard of care; the law does not guarantee that every fetal injury can be prevented.

How delayed recognition leads to injury

Both delayed recognition and lack of intervention are known causes of injury for babies. Fetal monitoring is tracking the baby’s heart rate. A reassuring fetal heart tracing generally shows moderate baseline variability.

There are known and consistent abnormalities in heart rate that medical staff are trained to look for. These changes can indicate that the baby is not getting enough oxygen or that blood flow to the placenta is compromised.

When concerning patterns are recognized, further evaluation and, when indicated, intervention should follow. As well, nursing staff should escalate care to a doctor, notifying them of the concerning changes in fetal heart rate.

Injury can occur when clinically significant abnormalities are not recognized or appropriately addressed. If intervention is not recommended and provided in a timely manner, the risk of injury increases.

Why parents aren’t told

Often, parents can feel as if they aren’t told what is happening or what happened that might have potentially contributed to a fetal injury. This is often not discussed with parents due to the technical nature of the data and the emotional toll that a traumatic birth can take on the family.

The high emotional state of birth and the aftermath can make it difficult to have complicated, technological conversations.

When a monitoring error may support a birth injury claim

In life, injury happens. Even when everything is done correctly, there are instances of birth injury. An injury claim may become relevant when data indicates there was a problem, medical records show that action required by the applicable standard of care was not taken, and that failure proximately caused the injury.

You don’t have to know that malpractice happened before asking for help. In the aftermath of a traumatic birth and an injury to a new family member, emotions can run high. You do not have to navigate this alone. The birth injury lawyers at Verderame Law Group Arizona Injury Lawyers are available to help you work through this heavy, complicated situation.

Perfection is not an expected part of medical care. Proper action when signs of distress are noticed is expected. If interventions fail to resolve the distress and further action is not taken, this may be a deviation from the applicable standard of care, depending on the circumstances.

Medical practitioners often tell parents that their baby’s injury was from a sudden and unavoidable emergency. The fetal monitoring strips may tell a different story. Courts and medical experts can identify the distinction. An emergency does not excuse prior inaction.

There is support available if you believe your child was injured due to improper monitoring or lack of action. You do not have to undertake this alone. Verderame Law Group’s birth injury lawyers are here to support you.